As of mid-November, Black Bull's current listings show one vacant homesite and three estate homes. Lot 32 Tillyfour is listed at $549,500 and is described as just over half an acre. 27 Bullseye asks $3,199,000 for 4,781 square feet on 0.623 acres, and 31 Rising Sun asks $3,299,000 for the same 4,781 square feet on 0.9 acres. A third home, 401 Black Bull Trail, is new construction with pricing on request and a completion target of December 2026.
Many other addresses on the same page are marked sold, including lots on Black Bull Trail and Bold Driver Lane and villas on Duckhorn Lane. The page doesn't show what they sold for. A buyer comparing paths this week is therefore working from asking prices, and the comparison is lopsided. There is one lot and two finished homes of the same size, at a moment when the community is building out a second phase.
In Black Bull right now, most of the premium for a finished home pays for time. A buyer who starts with a lot this winter should plan on more than a year before moving in.
The gap between the lot and the house, per square foot
The listed lot and the less expensive finished home are $2,649,500 apart in asking price as of mid-November. Spread across 4,781 square feet, that comes to about $554 per square foot. With 31 Rising Sun the figure is closer to $575. These are different parcels with different acreage, and asking prices are not closing prices, but the order of magnitude holds.
Now set that next to what area builders publish. Tri-River Construction's cost calculator, published in May 2025, gives a general range of $250 to $400 per square foot for homebuilding in the Gallatin Valley. It also notes that customization, site conditions, labor and supply costs, and permits move the figure. Venture Home Design put Montana custom homes at about $280 to $300 per square foot of above-grade living space in December 2024. That figure leaves out the lot, utilities, permitting, geotechnical work, the garage, landscaping, the driveway and sidewalks.
Those builder ranges are general figures, not luxury quotes, and the items they leave out add real money. Even at $400 a square foot, building 4,781 square feet comes to about $1.9 million before the excluded items. The finished homes ask several hundred thousand dollars more than that. Finishes, garages and landscaping account for part of that difference, and a move-in date measured in weeks rather than seasons accounts for much of the remainder.
Two Black Bull costs to add to the lot price
Two of the costs a lot buyer adds come from the community itself. Black Bull's Design Guidelines, revised as of January 2026, list a design review fee of $4 per livable square foot and a construction compliance deposit of $25,000 per property. For a house the size of 27 Bullseye, that review fee would be $19,124.
Next to a $2.6 million gap, those two figures are small. The bigger cost for a lot buyer comes from the calendar.
The months the finished-home price is buying
Builders who work in the valley publish similar timelines. Venture Home Design suggests allowing three or four months for design, HOA approval and permits, then about nine to twelve months for turnkey construction. DC Builders put custom builds in Bozeman at 12 to 18 months overall as of April 2025. For a 3,000-square-foot home, it estimated 9 to 12 months of construction, including two to three months to get the house dried in.
Winter makes those ranges longer. Venture Home Design notes that severe cold can pause outside work and bad roads can slow crews, with delays of "a week here and there, or longer." Using those published ranges, a buyer who starts design this winter would most likely move in somewhere between late 2027 and mid-2028. A buyer who closes on one of the finished homes could spend next summer on the course.
Club costs don't depend on which path you take
The club's published 2026 fees are the same whether an owner built or bought. The 2026 golf membership is a full-family membership with a $20,000 nonrefundable transfer fee, a $20,000 refundable deposit and $1,100 in monthly dues. The club says only a small number of golf memberships are available this year. The 2026 social membership for property owners is $425 a month plus a $1,000 annual food-and-beverage minimum. According to the club's October 19 to 25 newsletter, starting September 26, 2026, only food and nonalcoholic drinks count toward that minimum.
Membership terms differ from listing to listing. The 401 Black Bull Trail listing says social membership is required for that home and golf membership may be available. 27 Bullseye and 31 Rising Sun list membership as "Details on request." Each of those three homes lists HOA dues of $195 a month. For a lot buyer, a social membership at $425 a month comes to $5,100 a year in dues. If you join while the house is still being built, you could pay that for a year or more before you live there. The indoor season has started either way, and the club's newsletter says its golf simulator just opened for winter. Our earlier look at Black Bull's off-season covers the winter calendar.
The figures in this post are general information about published fees and asking prices. They aren't legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm your own situation with the right professional before you commit.
Where Phase 2 fits
The other way to get a lot is Black Bull's Phase 2 release. The community describes it as a limited set of homesites with views of the Gallatin Range, open now for priority registration, with construction under way. The Montana Department of Environmental Quality's construction stormwater permit list shows "BLACK BULL PHASE 2," held by Crown Holdings LLC, south of Baxter, north of Durston and west of Love, effective January 10, 2026.
For now, a buyer who wants to build this winter can choose Lot 32 Tillyfour or join the Phase 2 priority registry, which sends updates on project milestones and site release dates. The full community has 300 custom homesites ranging from a quarter acre to over an acre. It also has Golf Villas from 1,652 to 1,993 square feet, a 40-unit Cottages condominium, the 20-residence Fairways and the Bungalows for buyers who want less to maintain. More on the community is on our Black Bull neighborhood page.
If you're deciding between Lot 32, the Phase 2 registry or a finished estate home, Bert & Mikey Real Estate can help you put real numbers and a realistic move-in date on each path. Reach out to our team and we'll go through the Black Bull math with you.